Fob Watch gold hallmark year letters Question: I have a fob watch which I'm trying to date?
It's by Charles E Rose.
The marks inside are as follows:
- a diamond with Capitals JR we think is maker?
- then four symbols.. to the left an anchor (Birmingham?) to the top a crown?
- below 18 (18k gold?) and to the right a shield is either oval or rectangle with corners rounded.
- inside is a letter y.
The letter is lowercase and the tail of the y' curves from left to right and up slightly. The top 'forks ' of the y bend over to the left. We think its either 1898 or 1847 ?
Can you tell me which one or are we completely wrong?
Answer: Hi - Ann here, and many thanks for your query - and your patience.
The first thing you should realize is that the watch and the watch CASE could have been made by different people. As you say the watch is marked (on the face) Charles E Rose, while the case may have been made years before, in a different manufacturing base, in a different country by JR.
However tracking down Maker's Marks are the hardest part of any Hallmark as there is no central world registry of Maker's Marks.
The Anchor is the Assay office which you have rightfully identified as Birmingham while the Crown is the stamp signifying or guaranteeing quality - in this case 18ct gold.
So that leaves use with the SHAPE of the Stamp and the font used - in this case you say it is lowercase but your description of (italic) the letter could be misleading as I can't see it. Is it Old English for example?
The 1847 mark has cross lines through the body of the 'y' while the 1898 does not, plus the tail is as you described. The 1847 tail dips down at the end - so I would have to suggest the 1898 as being the correct date, as both stamps are similar being square with the corners cut off.
I don't know what you mean when you say 'shield is either oval or rectangle with corners rounded' as it can't be a Shield Shape nor can it be Oval?
If you don't own a Hallmarking book it is a great investment.
Hope you find this information useful.
Tags: assay office, cross lines, s marks, shield shape, year letters